Illinois students say principal censored story on district budget cuts

The front entrance of Plainfield East High School
Plainfield East High School in Plainfield, Illinois. (Photo By Jacnoc, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/116698172)

Plainfield East High School’s principal censored student reporting on district budget cuts last spring and now requires approval of every story before publication, according to multiple students on the East Side News staff.

The censored story reported that 27 district positions, including those of librarians and special education teachers, were being eliminated, according to the students who spoke to the Student Press Law Center. At the end of last school year, Principal Kai Freeman told them through their adviser that the article was inappropriate for school consumption. 

Mike Hiestand, a longtime SPLC attorney, said such censorship could violate the Illinois Speech Rights of Student Journalists Act, which generally gives student journalists editorial control of student media. The law narrowly permits school officials to restrict unlawful content such as libel, obscenity or invasions of privacy and content causing material and substantial disruption of school activities.

Labeling content as inappropriate for school is not enough of a justification under the law, Hiestand said, and it’s hard for him to see how a story on district budget cuts based on public information would meet the legal threshold for censorship.

Administrators, however, regularly try to censor student reporting that doesn’t put the school in a positive light, Hiestand said.

“Any story that a school official, for whatever reason, thinks might make the school look bad, that is not in line with the school’s public relations line, those are the stories that get canceled. Those are the stories that get censored,” Hiestand said. 

Freeman denied the allegations of censorship to SPLC, but did not respond to a request for additional information.

Students said Freeman had no direct contact with them regarding his decision to censor the story, which involved about five student journalists.

“We were pretty frustrated because we had worked really hard to get all the evidence and interviews compiled in a good story,” said Leila Abarca, who has worked at the East Side News for three years and is now editor in chief. “We all collaborated on it together, so it was pretty disheartening.” 

Tensions escalated further at the start of this school year when the East Side News published an editorial about the effects of a paper shortage, which was a result of budget cuts that eliminated the copy clerk position. 

Following that editorial, Freeman required all stories to be reviewed by him and two other staff members before publication, students said. Again, this was communicated to the newspaper staff members through their adviser. 

Students told SPLC that Freeman identifies edits while reviewing their articles, despite the newsroom having its own student editors. 

“It’s kind of like he’s an editor, too,” said Amaya Stafford, senior editor at the East Side News, “which I fear is not right.” 

Prior review, or requiring material to be submitted for approval before publication, isn’t illegal on its own, Hiestand said. But it’s a poor way to teach journalism, and it becomes unlawful once administrators use their authority to change protected speech, he said. 

SPLC has also warned that approval delays or systemic prior review can amount to illegal censorship, particularly when they create an environment of self-censorship.

“The local newspaper doesn’t have to submit their work to the mayor or to the city council before they publish it because that’s just not how it’s done. That’s just not good journalism,” Hiestand said. “The same thing kind of holds true for student journalists … where their main beat is the school or school administrators.” 

Despite feeling like their principal is trying to stifle their voices, the students said knowing Illinois has laws in place that protect them helps them feel more confident when reporting and publishing important stories. 

“We’re still writing whatever we believe is true and whatever we want without thinking if it’s going to be censored or not because now we’re more confident knowing that we have these laws,” Stafford said. 

“Our principal can kind of tell that we’re not gonna back down,” Abarca added. 

For more news like this on student journalism and the law, subscribe to the Student Press Law Center’s newsletter.