SUNSHINE WEEK: Results from our open-records test for campus crime data

The SPLC contacted 21 colleges and universities — two private institutions and one public school in each state. In each request we asked for two different records: a copy of the university’s crime log and incident reports for either types of crimes or specific incidents that occurred on campus.

Below is a full list of what we asked for from each school, what we received and how many calendar days it took to receive a final response (either the records we asked for or a denial of our request). Note that, for schools that required a formal, written request, the response time is calculated from the date we sent our letter. The response time for requests that still are pending was calculated as of the day this article was posted.

Return to main article

table.t1 {border: 1px solid #808080;border-collapse: collapse;}td.td1 {border: 1px solid gray;margin: 10px;font-size: small;}td.td2 {border: 1px solid gray;margin: 10px;font-size: small;background-color: #cccccc;}

School Public or Private Written Request Required? Requested Received Response Time
Georgia Oglethorpe University Private Yes Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes statistically recorded under the Clery Actfor three-week period Still pending 17 Days
LaGrange College Private No Copy of crime log and one specificincident report Received all records requested 5 Days
Savannah State University Public Yes Copy of crime log and two specificincident reports. Received all records requested 24 Days
Virginia Randolph College Private Yes Copy of specific incident reports(crime log is available on Web site) Request denied 8 Days
Shenandoah University Private Yes Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes statistically recorded under the Clery Act Still pending 38 Days
College of William and Mary Public Yes Copy of the crime log and onespecific incident report Received crime log;request for incident report still pending 9 Days for crime log; 10 Days since subsequent request for incident report
Kentucky Asbury University Private Yes Copy of one specific incidentreport (crime log was on Asbury web site) Request denied 2 Days
Bellarmine University Private No Copy of specific incident reports(crime log is available on Web site) Request denied 15 Days
Northern Kentucky University Public Yes Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes statistically recorded under the Clery Act Received all records requested 2 Days
Massachusetts Simmons University Private No Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes statistically recorded under the Clery Act Crime log received; request forincident reports denied 13 Days
Merrimack College Private No Copy of crime log for one week andone specific incident report Crime log received; request forincident report pending 2 Days for crime log; 14 Days since subsequentrequest for incident report
Framingham StateCollege Public No Copy of crime log for one week andone specific incident report Crime log and redacted incident report 14Days from request for crime log; 5 Days from subsequent request for incident report
Pennsylvania Lebanon Valley College Private No Copy of crime log for one week andone specific incident report Still pending 21 Days
Mercyhurst College Private Yes Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes statistically recorded under the Clery Act Crime log received; request forincident reports denied 13 Days
Lincoln University Public No Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crime statistically recorded under the Clery Act Received all records requested 2 Days
Tennessee Rhodes College Private No Copy of the crime log for one weekand one specific incident report. Received all records requested 1 Day for crime log;1 Day from subsequent request for incident report
Belmont University Private No Copy of crime log for one week andone specific incident report Received all records requested 16 Days for crime log;10 Days from subsequent request for incident report
East Tennessee State University Public No Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports recorded statistically under the Clery Act Received all records requested 2 Days
California Chapman University Private No Copy of crime log for one week andone specific incident report. Crime log received; request forincident report denied 7 Days
Santa Clara University Private Yes Copy of crime log for one week andincident reports for crimes recorded statistically under the Clery act. Crime log received; request forincident reports denied 5 days
Humboldt University Public Yes Copy of crime log for one week andfive specific incident reports. Crime log and redacted incidentreports 5 Days

Return to main article