WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Supreme Court has requested that the attorneys for an Illinois college administrator being sued for censoring her school newspaper file a response to the students’ petition, a move some say shows the Court is interested in case.
“Although your office has waived the right to file a response to the petition for a writ of certiorari…the Court nevertheless has directed this office to request that a response be filed,” stated a letter from the Supreme Court clerk to the Illinois Attorney General’s office dated Oct. 27 regarding the Hosty v. Carter case.
Long-time Supreme Court reporter Lyle Denniston wrote on his blog that the letter shows “the Supreme Court is showing some interest in the case.” Denniston has covered the court for various newspapers such as The Baltimore Sun and The Boston Globe over the course of nearly 50 years.
Three students from Governors State University in Illinois filed a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to hear the Hosty v. Carter case on Sept. 15.
In the June 20 decision, the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decided that the Supreme Court’s 1988 Hazelwood decision limiting high school student free expression rights could extend to college and university campuses.
When a respondent does not file a response or waives its right to a response, “if the Court believes that the petition may have some merit, the respondent will typically be asked for a response,” according to an excerpt from “Supreme Court Practice,” faxed to the Student Press Law Center by the Court’s public information office.
This action may force Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan to make clear her position on college press freedom, an issue that prompted debate before she received a national freedom of information award from the Society of Professional Journalists.
The justices were expected to discuss the petition soon, but the discussion will be delayed in order to consider the response from the attorney general. The attorney general must submit a response on or before Nov. 28, according to the letter.
“This does not assure review by the justices, but it does indicate an interest in the question at stake,” Denniston wrote on his blog.
—by Kim Peterson, SPLC staff writer
Read Related Coverage:
- Three briefs urge Supreme Court to hear Hosty v. Carter case News Flash, 10/20/2005
- PRESS RELEASE: Media groups urge high court to hear college censorship case News Flash, 10/20/2005
- University of Southern Indiana president signs public forum statement News Flash, 10/12/2005
- Student editorial criticizes Society of Professional Journalists for award recipient choice News Flash, 9/21/2005
- PRESS RELEASE: Illinois State University first to formally designate student paper as public forum News Flash, 9/20/2005
- Students petition U.S. Supreme Court to hear Hosty v. Carter case News Flash, 9/19/2005
- Memo linking California with Hosty decision worries students News Flash, 9/15/2005
- PRESS RELEASE: Students, advisers and professional journalists asked to press colleges on press freedom News Flash, 9/15/2005
- Appeals court extends Hazelwood to colleges Report, Fall 2005
- Student journalists “mildly” concerned by precedent setby Hosty ruling News Flash, 6/28/2005
- Free speech groups worry Hosty ruling will scale back students’ 1st Amendment rights News Flash, 6/23/2005
- Student media experts react to Governors State University ruling News Flash, 6/22/2005
- GSU student journalists will appeal 7th Circuit ruling to U.S. Supreme Court News Flash, 6/21/2005
- PRESS RELEASE: Appeals court invites havoc says Student Press Law Center News Flash, 6/21/2005
- U.S. court throws out censorship claim by Governors State U. student journalists News Flash, 6/20/2005
- Court hears arguments in Governors State case The Report, Spring 2004
- Federal appeals court hears arguments in Governors State censorship case News Flash, 1/8/2004
- On Jan. 8, all eyes on Seventh Circuit The Report, Winter 2003-04
- Battle for college free speech continues The Report, Fall 2003
- Seventh Circuit throws out pro college press decision, agrees to rehear Governors State case in front of full court News Flash, 6/26/2003
- SPLC PRESS RELEASE: Sweeping victory in Governors State censorship case News Flash, 4/10/2003
- Appellate court hears oral arguments in college censorship case News Flash, 1/08/2003
- First Amendment groups will argue college censorship case before appeals court News Flash, 9/25/2002
- SPLC PRESS RELEASE: National media organizations come to defense of college press freedom before appeals court News Flash, 8/5/2002
- Governors State U. case poses threat to student journalists News Flash, 6/13/2002
- Immunity given to 3 in Governors State case Report, Spring 2002
- Editors file lawsuit against state university for actions designed to paralyze publication Report, Spring 2001
- Editors sue university for First Amendment violations News Flash, 3/30/2001