CONNECTICUT — The mother of a student who was punished last
year for calling her administrators "douchebags" online said her
family will file a lawsuit against the school's principal for libel.
Lauren Doninger, mother of Avery Doninger, said she plans to file the
lawsuit next month against Lewis S. Mills High School Principal Karissa
Niehoff.
Problems between the Doningers and the Burlington, Conn., high school began
when administrators discovered Avery Doninger had referred to them using
offensive slang in her online journal. She was writing about a
battle-of-the-bands concert she believed would be canceled due to
"douchebags in central office," and she encouraged those reading her
blog to voice discontent by contacting the superintendent to "piss her off
more."
As a result of her blog entry, school officials removed her as class
secretary, prompting the Doningers to file a lawsuit claiming free speech
violations. A federal judge and then an appeals court rejected an initial part
of the claim in May, ending Avery Doninger's hope of being reinstated as
secretary before graduation. The remaining First Amendment claims are
pending.
The media attention surrounding the case has encouraged many individuals to
weigh in on the merits of Avery Doninger's punishment, including a man
from Wisconsin who e-mailed Niehoff about the case.
Niehoff wrote in reply that prior to the online journal incident,
"Avery had repeatedly been warned by her advisor to stop calling the
student council advisor and members names during her junior class meetings.
Thus, this was not the first incident of its kind with Avery." The man
forwarded the correspondence to Lauren Doninger.
The Doningers dispute Niehoff's assertion.
"She said things to perfect strangers about a 16-year old that just
aren't true," Lauren Doninger said. "And that's just
intolerable to me."
Avery Doninger agreed.
"Before this happened, I had always had a good relationship with Ms.
Niehoff," she said. "For her to go ahead and tell people all these
lies about me is just upsetting."
Messages left for Niehoff were not returned Wednesday or Thursday.
Lauren Doninger contacted the superintendent after she learned about the
remarks, and Newsday reported Niehoff received two days of unpaid
suspension for the incident.
When Doninger requested the rest of Niehoff's e-mails related to
Avery Doninger using the Freedom of Information Act, she said she found another
breach of her daughter's privacy from last July, which she said she
believes represents a pattern.
Said Doninger, "I think the irony is so rich. She made ill-considered
remarks and sent them out to cyberspace, and they came back to her. Just like
Avery."
By Kelsey Beltramea, SPLC staff writer